It’s been 5 years in the making. Still, Treasury has released exposure draft legislation to implement look-through CGT treatment for selling and purchasing businesses involving “earnout rights,” benefiting accountants in Sydney.
It is common in the sale of a business to decrease the buyer’s risk and to include provisions that adjust the sale price of a business depending on the subsequent performance of that business. These post-transaction payments are called earnouts. The tax implications of earnouts have been in limbo for many years.
The problem started in 2007 when the ATO issued a draft ruling (TR 2007/D10). The draft ruling complicated the pre-existing accepted practise of applying a “look-through” treatment to earnout arrangments (“look-through” means the CGT event has the same characteristics as the original sale and that the gain is only brought to account when the funds are received). The new draft ruling basically said that the “earnout right” must be valued, and that value was to be included in the capital proceeds for CGT purposes at the business’s sale date.
Under this approach, the “earnout right” was a separate CGT asset. This caused some problems, including:
- Valuation of the earnout right can be quite difficult
- CGT would be payable on the money you hadn’t yet received
- Small Business CGT Concessions were not available for capital gains concerning the earnout rights
Recognising these complications, in 2010, the Government proposed to amend the law to provide look-through treatment for qualifying earnout arrangements and released a discussion paper outlining the proposal. Since then, the ATO has provided administrative guidance, allowing taxpayers to either follow the draft ruling or adopt the look-through treatment based on the discussion paper.
While the new exposure draft legislation is quite different from the proposal in the discussion paper, it will overcome the abovementioned problems.
The seller will not pay tax on an earnout until the payment is received, and the Small Business CGT Concessions will be available if the conditions to access them are met. Also, rather than just including a new capital gain when each earn-out payment is received, the tax return for the year the original gain was received will need to be amended to increase the capital gain. Interest will not apply to the amended assessment. Any capital losses on a sale will be quarantined while the earnout right exists.
The new rules apply to the disposal of active assets, including shares in private companies that carry on businesses. There are some essential exclusions, though, such as:
- Sale of depreciating assets
- Earnouts that extend past 4 years
- The right to future financial benefits that are readily ascertainable at the time the right is created
- Arrangements where the parties are not at arm’s length
The new rules will apply to earnout rights created after 23 April 2015. Taxpayers who have relied on the previous discussion paper in preparing their tax returns will be protected under the “announced but unenacted measures” provisions. This essentially means that the ATO can’t amend those returns.
This is complex legislation, so contact us if you are affected by the above.
*Correct as of May 2015
Disclaimer – Kreston Stanley Williamson has produced this article to serve its clients and associates. The information contained in the article is of general comment only and is not intended to be advice on any particular matter. Before acting on any areas in this article, you must seek advice about your circumstances. Liability is limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.